Skip to content

Your one stop sweet tooth destination

Shop Our Sweets

Treat Yourself to a Monthly Cookie Fix - Subscribe Today!

Subscribe Here!

Treat Yourself to a Monthly Cookie Fix - Subscribe Today!

Subscribe Here!

Treat Yourself to a Monthly Cookie Fix - Subscribe Today!

Subscribe Here!

Your one stop sweet tooth destination

Shop Our Sweets

Your one stop sweet tooth destination

Shop Our Sweets

Your one stop sweet tooth destination

Shop Our Sweets

Butcher Shop Bake Company

High quality, small batch cookies, brownies, and other original sweet treats

Home
About
- Testimonials
Shop Local
Contact Us
- My account
- Cart
- Checkout
Order Now

mystery cookie

Showing the single result

Mystery Cookie
$2.00 Add to cart

Search Our Products

Search

Cart

Categories

Apparel
Brownies
Gift Cards
Gourmet Cookies
- Gluten Free Cookies
- Gourmet Protein Cookies
Mini Cookies

Select Delivery Option

Learn More About Subscriptions
*Price includes shipping

Product tags

bakery baking banana birthday blueberry breakfast brownie butterscotch cake caramel cheesecake chocolate chocolate chip chocolate chips cinnamon coconut coffee cookie cookie butter cookies dark chocolate dessert Fall food frosting fruit fudge gourmet cookie lemon marshmallow milk chocolate oatmeal oreo peanut butter protein cookie small business smores snack strawberry sugar summer sweets toffee white chocolate wisconsin

Special Order Request?

Please inquire for large or custom order requests to see if we can accommodate

To reduce spam submissions, please provide the correct answer below.

5+63 =

Δ

Contact Us

info@butchershopbakecompany.com

Submit Flavor Suggestion

View Ordering Information

Local? Get Yours Today!

Follow Us

Don’t Miss Out

Enter your email address to receive the latest announcements, new flavors and discount offers.

* indicates required

© 2026 Butcher Shop Bake Company. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service